| 7 Dec 2025 | FA Cup | Blackpool - Carlisle United | A | Blackpool | €0.29m | €0.06m |
| 1 Nov 2025 | FA Cup | Reading - Carlisle United | A | Reading | €0.19m | €0.06m |
| 2 Nov 2024 | FA Cup | Carlisle United - Wigan Athletic | H | Carlisle | €0.22m | €0.14m |
| 4 Nov 2023 | FA Cup | Leyton Orient - Carlisle United | A | London | €0.31m | €0.14m |
| 26 Nov 2022 | FA Cup | Walsall - Carlisle United | A | Walsall | €0.17m | €0.06m |
| 5 Nov 2022 | FA Cup | Carlisle United - Tranmere Rovers | H | Carlisle | €0.20m | €0.12m |
| 4 Dec 2021 | FA Cup | Carlisle United - Shrewsbury Town | H | Carlisle | €0.14m | €0.06m |
| 6 Nov 2021 | FA Cup | Carlisle United - Horsham | H | Carlisle | €0.13m | €0.06m |
| 15 Jan 2020 | FA Cup | Carlisle United - Cardiff City | H | Carlisle | €0.21m | €0.13m |
| 4 Jan 2020 | FA Cup | Cardiff City - Carlisle United | A | Cardiff | €0.28m | €0.07m |
| 10 Dec 2019 | FA Cup | Carlisle United - Forest Green Rovers | H | Carlisle | €0.08m | €0.04m |
| 30 Nov 2019 | FA Cup | Forest Green Rovers - Carlisle United | A | Nailsworth | €0.07m | €0.03m |
| 8 Nov 2019 | FA Cup | Dulwich Hamlet - Carlisle United | A | — | €0.16m | €0.06m |
| 1 Dec 2018 | FA Cup | Lincoln City - Carlisle United | A | Lincoln | €0.31m | €0.06m |
| 10 Nov 2018 | FA Cup | Crewe Alexandra - Carlisle United | A | Crewe | €0.12m | €0.05m |
| 16 Jan 2018 | FA Cup | Sheffield Wednesday - Carlisle United | A | Sheffield | €0.64m | €0.07m |
| 6 Jan 2018 | FA Cup | Carlisle United - Sheffield Wednesday | H | Carlisle | €0.38m | €0.29m |
| 19 Dec 2017 | FA Cup | Carlisle United - Gillingham | H | Carlisle | €0.11m | €0.05m |
| 2 Dec 2017 | FA Cup | Gillingham - Carlisle United | A | Gillingham | €0.16m | €0.06m |
| 4 Nov 2017 | FA Cup | Carlisle United - Oldham Athletic | H | Carlisle | €0.19m | €0.11m |
| 3 Dec 2016 | FA Cup | Carlisle United - Rochdale | H | Carlisle | €0.22m | €0.14m |
| 6 Nov 2016 | FA Cup | St Albans City - Carlisle United | A | — | €0.17m | €0.06m |